How to Know If Your Jewelry Is Worth Selling

Jewelry can be beautiful, meaningful—and surprisingly valuable. But how do you know when it’s time to part with it? Whether you’re clearing out your collection, downsizing, or simply curious, understanding the true worth of your items is the first step. Here’s what to look for.

1. Outdated Style or Damaged Pieces

Not every piece of jewelry stands the test of time. If you have:

• Broken chains or clasps
• Missing stones
• Designs you haven’t worn in years

These items might still carry strong resale value. Gold, silver, and even platinum content often matters more than aesthetic appeal. Don’t assume that visible wear means a piece isn’t worth anything—buyers often pay based on metal weight and purity.

2. No Emotional Attachment

Sentiment plays a major role in keeping jewelry. But if you don’t feel connected to a piece—whether it was inherited, gifted, or from a past chapter of life—it may be better turned into cash or used toward something new. Many sellers find emotional relief in letting go of jewelry that no longer reflects who they are.

3. Gold and Silver Content

Older pieces, especially vintage or estate jewelry, are more likely to be made from high-purity materials. Even if a piece looks modest, it could be:

• Solid gold (10k, 14k, 18k, etc.)
• Sterling silver
• Platinum

These materials are always in demand, and their value fluctuates based on live market rates. What might seem like costume jewelry could be worth far more than expected.

Why It Pays to Get a Professional Opinion

Still unsure about what your jewelry is worth? A no-obligation, professional evaluation can give you clarity. At PGS Gold & Coin, we offer free evaluation so you can:

• Understand the exact metal content
• Get a real-time market value estimate
• Learn whether it’s worth selling, holding, or repurposing
  

No pressure. Just facts—and a clearer picture of what your jewelry is truly worth.

Why Choose PGS Gold & Coin?

• Trusted by families across Chicago and the suburbs since 2008
• Certified, knowledgeable appraisers on staff
• Transparent pricing with no hidden fees
• Multiple locations and a discreet, welcoming environment
• Optional on-site estate consultations for large or complex collections

We’ve earned the trust of thousands of people across Chicago and the suburbs for over 15 years, offering a professional, friendly experience from start to finish.

Visit PGS Gold & Coin at one of our convenient Chicagoland locations, or find us online at staging.pgsgoldandcoin.com

PGS Gold & Coin — Chicago’s Trusted Gold Buyers Since 2008