Thinking of selling your jewelry but don’t want the hassle or risk of online listings and pawn shops? Selling locally can be a safer, faster, and more rewarding option—if you know where to start. Here’s how to maximize your return and peace of mind.

1. Choose a Trusted Local Buyer

Start by researching reputable buyers in your area. Look for:

  • Strong online reviews
  • Industry accreditations
  • Years of local service

A business with a long-standing reputation is more likely to offer transparent pricing, expert staff, and a secure experience. Avoid pop-up gold buyers or temporary events that often lowball or pressure you into selling.

2. Bring in a Range of Items

Don’t limit yourself to just one type of jewelry. A qualified buyer will assess:

  • Gold and silver pieces (even broken ones)
  • Diamond and gemstone jewelry
  • Designer or vintage pieces
  • Estate and inherited collections

At PGS Gold & Coin, you can bring in all types of jewelry for a free evaluation. You’ll receive a breakdown of what your items are made of and what they’re worth on today’s market.

Note. For those needing formal documentation for insurance or legal purposes, professional written appraisals are available.

 

3. Skip the Middlemen

Many jewelry sellers lose value by working through brokers or consignment shops. To avoid delays and extra fees:

  • Sell directly to a local buyer who appraises and purchases in-house
  • Avoid pawn shops offering only a fraction of real market value
  • Stay away from online listings that carry scams, low offers, or slow payments

Local direct buyers like PGS offer instant payment, clear explanations, and no hidden costs.

 

Why Choose PGS Gold & Coin?

  • Trusted by families across Chicago and the suburbs since 2008
  • Certified, knowledgeable appraisers on staff
  • Transparent pricing with no hidden fees
  • Multiple locations and a discreet, welcoming environment
  • Optional on-site estate consultations for large or complex collections

We’ve earned the trust of thousands of people across Chicago and the suburbs for over 15 years, offering a professional, friendly experience from start to finish.

The Bottom Line

From broken gold chains to high-end diamond jewelry, selling locally doesn’t have to be complicated. When you work with a trusted, in-house buyer like PGS Gold & Coin,
you get real value—without the guesswork.

 

Visit PGS Gold & Coin at one of our convenient Chicagoland locations, or find us online at staging.pgsgoldandcoin.com

 

PGS Gold & Coin — Chicago’s Trusted Gold Buyers Since 2008